16 March 2011

Dorothy the Assassin?

Last month I noted how the Fables spin-off comic book Cinderella: Fables Are Forever is using the character of Dorothy Gale as the heroine’s nemesis. Or actually a grown-up Dorothy Gale who looks a lot more like Judy Garland than like John R. Neill’s blonde.

I found an interview at the Outhousers with Chris Roberson, scripter of that series, explaining how he found this take on Dorothy:

Last year my wife and I were watching The Wiz one night on DVD, and I noticed something about Dorothy Gale I'd never thought about before: namely, that she is a killer for hire.

When Dorothy goes to kill the Wicked Witch for the Wizard in exchange for a trip back home, she is agreeing to commit murder in exchange for pay, essentially. She killed the Wicked Witch of the East by accident at the beginning of the story when Dorothy's house landed on her, but when she takes out the Wicked Witch of the West it is a premeditated, conscious act. So by the end of that first Oz story, Dorothy has killed two witches and profited from it.

I figured that maybe she learned that she had a taste for it, and after the end of her story went on to become a PROFESSIONAL killer for hire. . . .
Roberson’s take on the basic Wizard of Oz plot reminded me of a summary of the MGM movie I’d once read, which the internet tells me was composed by Rick Polito of the Marin Independent Journal:
Transported to a surreal landscape, a young girl kills the first person she meets and then teams up with three strangers to kill again.
As I wrote earlier, I authored a Baum Bugle article called “Dorothy the Conqueror.” It points out that the little girl and her company subdue, depose, or put into vassalage the following rulers: the Wicked Witch of the East, the Queen of the Field Mice, the Wicked Witch of the West, the King of the Flying Monkeys, the Wizard, the China Princess, the giant spider, the Chief Wheeler, Princess Langwidere, the Nome King, the Mangaboo Princess, and the King of the Gargoyles. And that’s just her first three adventures. So I agree that Dorothy certainly develops a taste for putting things right. I wouldn’t go so far as saying she’s a contract killer, but it’s a better fit for her than for some other heroines.

In this publicity interview Roberson also said:
there is a lot more creepy stuff in the [Oz] books than we ever saw on screen. The Technicolor Oz is a pretty domesticated place, and one that audiences are very comfortable with, but the Oz of the books has all of these odd little creatures and concepts scattered around the landscape, that make good fodder for stories like this.
We could therefore see a lot more of Dorothy and Oz in Cinderella just as Bill Willingham’s version of Ozma goes superhero in Fables.

5 comments:

Don P said...

Dorothy did not kill the Wicked Witch of the East. Yes, Dorothy’s house (actually Auntie Em’s house) fell on the Wicked Witch of the East resulting in her death, but Dorothy had no control or responsibility of that accidental death. The death was caused by the tornado picking up the house and dropping it on the witch. If you think Dorothy was somehow responsible for the death, I’m willing to hear your attempt at an explanation of how she was responsible.

Don P said...

Now that I think about it (it has been a few years since I saw the movie) the death of the Wicked Witch of the West was also an accident. I seem to remember that Dorothy was to bring back the witches broom, but I don’t remember if she was required to kill the witch. Yes, there was probably no way to get the broom without killing the witch so there could be an argument for I ntent… but the actual killing of the Wicked Witch of the West was, in reality, the result of an accident. Dorothy was trying to save the Scarecrow who was on fire and accidentally got water on the witch in the process causing her to melt. I doubt that Dorothy was aware of the fact that getting water on the witch would cause her to melt and getting water on the witch was not the intent of Dorothy throwing the water at that time.

J. L. Bell said...

You’ll have to take that up with Chris Roberson, the comics scripter who a decade ago made the Fables version of Dorothy a killer for hire.

Anonymous said...

The plot summary credited to Polito was written by Lee Winfrey of the Philadelphia Inquirer, who retired as tv and film reviewer in 2001.

J. L. Bell said...

The evidence shows Winfrey picked up a joke by Polito, who was credited in the original newspaper but whose name was cropped out of a widely circulated digital image.

See: https://tumblr.austinkleon.com/post/36512879652